Pit Boss vs Traeger Pellet Grill: Which One You Choose?

Pit Boss vs Traeger Comparison

​In a Rush? Here's our Recommendation!

Pit Boss 700FB Pellet Grill


Key features:

  • ​700 Square Inches Grilling Surface
  • ​Dial-in digital board with LED read-out
  • ​Dome thermometer
  • ​Standard flame broiler
  • ​Porcelain coated cooking grids
  • ​Auto igniter
  • ​Start/stop cycle

Wood pellet grills combine the ease of an electric starter with the flavor of compressed wood pellets.

They provide you with flavor profiles and moisture that only hardwood cooking can achieve.

Knowing yourself, your wants, and your needs will lead you to making the best selection, and you may want to consider the most popular brands.

In the quest of finding the best pellet grill, we have taken interest in two of the world’s top brands: Pit Boss and Traeger.

The Pit Boss vs. Traeger battle is fierce, but we intend to settle it today by providing you with a complete comparison of the two, and the best products each brand has to offer.

Let’s get started!

Pit Boss Overview

Pit Boss is a brand known for its uniqueness, innovativeness, craftsmanship, and durability. Not to mention their family approach and style to business.

Pit Boss understands what you need to prepare as well as serve the best in first-class, wood pellet gourmet goodness.

This brand uses cooking grade wood pellets that are all-natural for fuel. Their grills are built to last and engineered to provide immediate success.

Their models are outfitted with a dial-in digital control center that is remarkably easy to operate, giving you complete control of the grilling temperature.

Pit Boss achieves convection by implementing a number of techniques. Their exhaust structure allows for even air circulation, allowing you to attain uniform heat.

To establish the truth about Pit Boss, we’ve set Traeger as the perfect weighing scale.


Traeger Overview

Wood pellet grills were first presented in the 1990s by a trivial company in Oregon called Traeger, which sparked a new way of smoking and grilling.

A fairly recent innovation in wood-fired grills is provided by Traeger. Their natural, wood pellet grills feature the finest grilling accessories.

Traeger grills are packed with exceptional hardwood flavors from savory mesquite, to sweet cherry as well as everything you BBQ, braise, roast, bake, smoke, or grill.

Their models can be used for both direct cooking and smoking, they are some of the best of both worlds.

As you can see, both of these brands are quite innovative in their design and performance. Yet, there are still some significant differences that separates them.

Let’s go ahead and find out what the differences are.


​Pit Boss vs. Traeger Detailed ​Comparison

Construction

It is the construction that determines the durability of a grill. In light of this, there aren’t many brands that can outshine the construction of Traeger grills.

For example, consider Traeger Lil Tex Elite and Pit Boss 700FB. Both grills are engineered from cast iron with a porcelain coat finish. But Traeger still presents a better construction.

The porcelain coating on both grills prevents food from sticking, but Traeger has also used a more effective non-stick material.

Most Traeger models have heavy-duty cart design with super strong wheels that are fitted with locking casters.  

Verdict: Traeger wins this category.


Temperature

One of the most important factors when shopping for a wood pellet grill is temperature. In fact, the cooking ability of any smoker grill relies mostly on the control board.

Traeger grills are capable of achieving up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, while Pit Boss grills are capable of achieving up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit.

It is clear from the above figures that Pit Boss offers more cooking temperature ranges compared to Traeger.

Both brands have smoker, medium, and high cooking temperature ranges. They also have a digital controller that maintains the ideal temperature.

What is most impressive about these two brands is that they both have auto shutoff cycles. They will shut down when the maximum temperature is exceeded.

Verdict: Pit Boss wins this category.


Cooking Space

When shopping for a wood pellet grill, cooking space is an important consideration. You don’t want to buy a unit that will not satisfy your grilling requirements.

By design, Pit Boss units offer more cooking space than Traeger. For example, Pit Boss 700SC provides a total cooking area of 700 square inches, while Traeger Lil Tex Elite offers 418 square inches.

Unlike most Traeger designs, Pit Boss models come with an extra upper cooking rack. Using the upper rack is possible with the inclusion of an exhaust system and a proprietary dome heat shield.

As far as Pit Boss vs. Traeger battle goes, Pit Boss offers a more favorable option when cooking for a larger group of people. Although, there are a few Traeger models that come with a larger cooking surface.

Verdict: Pit Boss wins this category.


Hopper Size

When deciding between the two wood pellet grills, the hopper size matters a lot.

The hopper is the one storing the pellet fuel the grill uses. Therefore, you need to settle for a model with enough hopper capacity to successfully complete cooking without refilling.

Both Traeger and Pit Boss are well-engineered with sufficient slope for feeding wood pellets into the auger system.

They both have a flat bottom and they will allow the auger feed system to run dry before the hopper is completely empty. This gives you adequate time to refill.

The main difference between these two models is the hopper capacity. Most Pit Boss units have a hopper capacity of up to 20 pounds; while Traeger units have a hopper capacity of up to 18 pounds.

Verdict: Pit Boss wins this category.


Versatility

Whether it is cooking a wood-fired pizza or smoking ribs, you need a grill that has superior versatility.

Pit Boss provides you with the following ways of cooking: smoke, grill, charcoal grill, roast, sear, and BBQ; while Traeger provides you with the following ways of cooking: roast, grill, smoke, bake, braise, and BBQ.

Both brands don’t just grill or smoke food. They do more, and they make sure that your food gets flavored with astounding wood-fired taste.

Verdict: It is a tie as far as this category goes.


Price

The last category on our Pit Boss vs. Traeger battle is the price. This is particularly important if you are working with a tight budget.

According to our analysis, Pit Boss units seem to be reasonably priced when compared to Traeger. You would make a similar observation if you consider similar-sized units.

However, we can’t decisively state that all Pit Boss units are cheaper than Traeger. It depends on what you are looking for on the market.

Verdict: Pit Boss wins this category.  



Top 5 Pit Boss Pellet Grills:

If you are looking to produce top-quality barbeque in your own backyard, look no further than the Pit Boss 700FB.


This is one of the most versatile cooking appliance ever built by the brand with a standard flame broiler for sauté, stir fry, or frame broil dinner in just a few minutes.


Operating the 700FB is easy; simply load the pellet hopper with your favorite hardwood colors, turn the dial to your desired hotness, and get ready to serve within ten minutes.


The grill automatically feeds itself pellets, and adjusts to your desired cooking temperature between one hundred and eighty and five hundred degrees Fahrenheit.


Digital control panel provides you with a wide range of cooking or grilling temperatures. The display is crystal clear, showing the precise temperature.  


Key features:

  • ​700 Square Inches Grilling Surface
  • ​Dial-in digital board with LED read-out
  • ​Dome thermometer
  • ​Standard flame broiler
  • ​Porcelain coated cooking grids
  • ​Auto igniter
  • ​Start/stop cycle


Pros:

  • ​Integrated with auto start and cool down
  • ​Sufficiently large hopper capacity
  • ​LED read-out allows for easy reading of the temperature
  • ​High temp powder coat finish improves durability
  • ​Large cooking surface allows for one-time cooking
  • ​Convection technique circulates heat evenly for effective cooking


Cons:

  • ​May overcook food, needs to be monitored closely

The Classic Wood Fired Pellet Grill by Pit Boss will transform the way you cook in your own backyard. It offers versatility at a whole new level.


There is so much you can do, such as smoke, wood-fired pizza, bake, braise, broil, grill, deep fry, and world-class barbeque.


This model comes standard with heavy-duty wheels that are all-terrain friendly, making it easy for you to move the unit outdoors. There is also a bottom shelf for holding other accessories.


It is integrated with a digital control board and a push button for quick heat recovery. The control knob allows you to select the appropriate cooking temperature.


The unit comes with two meat knobs that allow you to effectively monitor the internal temperature of two meat pieces.


Key features:

  • ​700 Square Inches Grilling Surface
  • ​Digital Control Board
  • ​Dome thermometer
  • ​Innovated Flame broiler
  • ​Bottom and upper cooking grids


Pros:

  • ​More than one cooking methods
  • ​Sufficient grilling area for one-time cooking
  • ​Integrated flame broiler allows for fast cooking
  • ​Easy to set and monitor temperature with digital panel
  • ​Extremely easy to dispose and change pellet flavors


Cons:

  • ​A little bit heavy for transportation

Do you love world class barbequing? The 72700S Pellet Grill by Pit Boss is what you need. It is our third best choice from this outstanding brand.


The 72700S provides you with a unique juiciness achieved from slow cooking. You can roast, braise, bake, grill, smoke, char-grill, sear, and barbeque – all in one.


This unit automatically moves wood pellets into the electric burner at a consistent rate for even heating. The fire will hardly come in contact with the food, preventing charring.


After plugging the Pit Boss 72700S in power, just tell the unit whether you would like to smoke or cook by turning the temperature dial, providing that great wood flavor.


The integrated digital temperature control allows for easy temperature setup and monitoring. In fact, you can step away once you have confirmed the desired temperature on the display.


Key features:

  • ​700 Square Inches Grilling Surface
  • ​Digital temperature control
  • ​Dome thermometer
  • ​Side shelf
  • ​8-In-1 versatility
  • ​Upgraded cart design


​Pros:

  • ​Adequate cooking area for cooking a variety of food at once
  • ​Digital temperature panel allows for precise control of hotness
  • ​More versatility with 8-in-1 cooking options
  • ​High-temp powder coated exterior is highly durable
  • ​Delivers superb textures and flavors


Cons:

  • ​May fail to hold temperatures in a low smoking range

Experience the versatility of Pit Boss with the 700SC. This unique grill will allow you to charbroil a steak, grill burgers, bake biscuits, and smoke ribs at the comfort of your backyard.


One of the most innovative parts of the design is the flame broiler, which provides you with total control of direct flame cooking.


There is an extra cooking rack, which increases the cooking area. This provides you with more than enough space for most of your cooking needs.


This unit features a digital control panel with a wide range of settings. When you are ready to grill, all you have to do is power up the grill and set the appropriate temperature.


The grill grates are made out of porcelain coat steel, which is non-stick and has superior heat retention.


Key features:

  • ​700 Square Inches of Grilling Surface
  • ​Digital Temperature Control
  • ​High Performing Flame Broiler
  • ​Large Hopper
  • ​Enclosed Cabinet
  • ​Dome Thermometer

Pros:

  • ​Large cooking surface allows you to cook most of your food at once
  • ​Super easy to use digital controls
  • ​Large hopper capacity eliminates frequent refilling of pellets
  • ​Fully enclosed cabinet provides storage space
  • ​Bottle opener for opening refreshments


Cons:

  • ​Does not offer low and high smoke options

Are you looking for a large capacity grill that will transform your cooking experience? Look no further than the 71820FB.


The digital temperature control and lid thermometer allow for precise temperatures. This means you can rely on even heat for perfect grilling.


The use of all-natural wood pellets instead of propane allows you to enjoy wood flavors with a simple dial of the temperature control.


The Pit Boss 71820FB offers 820 square inches of cooking space, and a temperature range of 180 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.


This unit is also quite durable. It is constructed with heavy-duty steel and solid legs, making it strong and long-lasting. Also, it is equipped with outdoor-friendly wheels for movement.


Key features:

  • ​820 Square Inches Grilling Space
  • ​Dial-In Temperature Equipped With LED Read-Out
  • ​Flame Broiler
  • ​Porcelain Coated Cooking Grids
  • ​Dome Thermometer


Pros:

  • ​No need for rotisserie, thanks to convection cooking
  • ​LED lit dial-in temperature control is easy to read
  • ​Flame broiler allows for flame searing
  • ​Large cooking area for cooking lots of stuff at once
  • ​Versatile cooking options available


Cons:

  • ​Does not have a pellet cleanout

Top 5 Traeger Wood Pellet Grills:

This is the most versatile grill you can own. You can grill, braise, roast, bake, smoke, and barbeque all with this amazing unit.


Unlike conventional units, this superior wood fire model gives you that delicious wood flavor everybody likes. Taste the difference.


No more messing with propane tanks or hard to light charcoal, the Traeger uses natural wood pellets that offers superb wood-fired flavor.


The Traeger Renegade Elite is a smart, digital grill that does all the work for you. It automatically feeds in the natural hardwood to maintain the ideal cooking temperature.


You simply set the temperature, turn it on, walk away, and enjoy the day. It is that simple and you cannot mess it up.


With the inclusion of the convection fan, the hot air circulates, cooking your food evenly. There is no hot or cold spots on the grill.


The built-in heat shield protects your meat from flare-ups. You can use this unit all year round. It works just as good in the winter as it does in the summer.


Key features:

  • ​380 Square Inch Cooking Area
  • ​6-In-1 Versatility
  • ​Digital Elite Controller
  • ​Electronic Auto-Start Ignition
  • ​Easy-To-Clean Porcelain Grates
  • ​Wire Front Prep Rack
  • ​Tool Caddy Rack


Pros:

  • ​6-in-1 versatility offers more cooking options
  • ​Easy to assemble and disassemble for cleaning
  • ​Remarkably fast cooking time of about 20 to 30 minutes
  • ​​No hot spots, cold spots or flare-ups
  • ​Easy to start with auto ignition
  • ​Able to maintain precise temperature with digital elite controller


Cons:

  • ​Cooking area may not be sufficient for some users
  • ​May experience inconsistency in temperature levels

The second top-rated Traeger grill in our list is the Lil Tex Elite. It comes with an array of useful features, some of them small and some big. 


With the Lil Tex Elite, you don’t have to use charcoal or gas anymore. This amazing unit has made grilling a lot better.


You pay for versatile barbeque cooking, including BBQ, braise, roast, bake, smoke, and grill. You can cook slow and low or fast and hot.


One of the most appealing attributes of this model is the grilling area, which is 646 square inches. You can fit 9 racks of smoked ribs, 32 hot dogs, 6 whole chickens, or 24 burgers.


The digital elite controller makes grilling remarkably easy. With a clear view of the cooking temperature, you know the precise hotness at which your food is cooking.


The construction is not only easy to maintain, but also durable. It has a heavy-duty steel construction, wheels fitted with locking casters, and porcelain grill grates that are super easy to clean.


Key features:

  • ​640 Square Inches Grilling Area
  • ​Digital Elite Controller
  • ​Electronic Auto Start Ignition
  • ​Porcelain Cooking Grates
  • ​Wheels Fitted With Locking Casters
  • ​Induction Fun
  • ​6-In-1 Versatility


Pros:

  • ​A larger cooking area that can hold 6 whole chickens
  • ​Auto start ignition for easy start-up
  • ​Super easy to manage temperature with digital controller
  • ​Induction fun operation eliminates hot or cold spots
  • ​Highly versatile cooking options


Cons:

  • ​Hot and fast operation may fail

The Pro 34 BRZ is one of the most popular, original Traeger pellet grill designed for outdoor enthusiasts.


This unit features a pellet hopper with an adequate capacity situated on the left side. The wood pellets are available in a variety of wood types, allowing you to match the flavor.


The Pro 34 BRZ comes with a digital pro controller panel, through which you can turn on the unit and set the ambient cooking temperature.


After setting the desired temperature, the auger system at the bottom of the hopper starts turning, transporting the pellets toward the fire pot in the lower section.


This unit is also fitted with a draft induction fan, which when activated, circulates air throughout the grill. This process helps to regulate temperature.


Key features:

  • ​884 Square Inch Grilling Area
  • ​Digital Pro Controller
  • ​Dual Meat Probes
  • ​Hopper Clean-Out
  • ​Sawhorse Chassis
  • ​Draft Induction Fan


Pros:

  • ​A larger cooking area compared to other Traeger grills
  • ​Controller panel with advanced grilling logic
  • ​Easy to check the internal temperature of the meat with the dual probes
  • ​Sawhorse chassis provides additional stability
  • ​Draft induction fan allows for superior temperature regulation


Cons:

  • ​May experience drop in temperature by about 30 degrees Fahrenheit

Ranking fourth in our list of the top-rated Traeger grills is the Bronson. A well-made wood pellet grill designed for grilling, smoking, and barbequing.


This is the smallest size in Traeger lineup with a cooking area of 300 square inches. This is a really nice usable size for a small family or gathering.


It comes with a digital elite controller with temperatures ranging from 82 to 190 degrees Celsius. The system is also integrated with a shutdown cycle.


The controller has a two-probe design, which allows you to closely monitor the internal temperature of your meat or food.


Regardless of its small size, you still get versatile barbecue cooking options, including: BBQ, braise, roast, bake, smoke, or grill.


Key features:

  • ​300 Square Inches Grilling Area
  • ​Digital Elite Controller
  • ​6-In-1 Versatility
  • ​Auto Start Ignition
  • ​​Sawhorse Chassis
  • ​Heavy-Duty Wheels For All-Terrain
  • ​Induction Fan


Pros:

  • ​Easy to maintain cooking temperature with probes
  • ​Numerous cooking options
  • ​Easy to ignite with auto start ignition
  • ​Sawhorse chassis improves stability
  • ​Superb temperature regulation with induction fan


Cons:

  • ​A very small cooking area
  • ​May present temperature error on the display

Like the Bronson, the Junior Elite is also small and portable. A perfect model for outdoor fanatics. It is small, yes, but it is also powerful.


This may not be the most favorite model for most people out there, probably because of its size. But it can be a game changer if you give it a try.


Designed for tailgating, travelling, and small households. It can easily hold around three rib racks or eighteen hot dogs at once.


Apart from the small cooking area of 300 square inches, we bet you would love the digital elite controller that makes temperature monitoring super easy.


Auto start ignition simplifies operation, and the porcelain grill grates are not only non-stick but also super easy to clean once you are done cooking.


Key features:

  • ​300 Square Inches Grilling Surface
  • ​Digital Elite Controller
  • ​6-In-1 Versatility
  • ​Easy-To-Clean Porcelain Grates
  • ​Auto Start Ignition
  • ​Induction Fan


Pros:

  • ​Easy to use digital elite controller with a knob
  • ​Well-made steel body that is rust resistant
  • ​Occupies less room space
  • ​Superior cooking versatility
  • ​Easy to run with auto start ignition


Cons:

  • ​Set temperature may fluctuate
  • ​May not be ideal for smoking

​Conclusion

As far as quality and cost-based value are concerned, the Pit Boss is a better choice than the Traeger. In terms of construction, Traeger provides durable and stable designs.

If you consider the total cooking area, most Pit Boss models offer a larger cooking surface. Only a handful of Traeger units provide more than 700 square inches of space.

Another striking feature that separates these two brands is the cooking temperature. Pit Boss units have a wider range compared to Traeger.

What we found most impressive is the versatility of both brands as far as cooking options are concerned.

They both have at least six cooking options, including grill, braise, roast, bake, smoke, char-grill, sear, and barbeque.

According to this Pit Boss vs. Traeger assessment, Pit Boss wins as far as cost-effectiveness, cooking space, hopper capacity, and cooking temperature are concerned.

However, the final and decisive buying decision depends entirely on you. Enjoy world-class barbequing of your own choosing.

​Good luck!

BBQVibe
 

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: